Trade Review Series: Lessons from Successful and Failed Trades #1

Intro

  • In this series I will review trades sent in by other traders who have asked for feedback
  • I really appreciate their courage to do so, so we can all improve!
  • Not enough of the trading community do this – I will also review my own good and bad trades.

Process to Review Trades

  • Market Cycle
    • Trend vs Trading Range – Always in?
    • Did the trade match the structure at the time
  • Entry – Strong / Weak / Mistake*
  • Scale-ins / Add-ons – Strong / Weak / Mistake
  • Exit – Strong / Weak / Mistake
  • Strong = I would do it again
  • Weak = I would not do that again exactly
  • Mistake = Execution error

Video

  • I made a video on this here:

Trade 1:

Suggested exercises to practice:

  • Spike and H1 video
  • Which entry for which trade? Buy the close, Buy 1 Tick above the High entry
  • Reversals
  • Did not exit the High 2 when it failed
  • Scaled into a failed trade / opposite breakout
  • Exit criteria – Exit on breakout + follow-through would have been earlier by one bar

Trade 2:

Suggested exercises to practice:

  • Missed the wedge bottom reversal entry
  • Always in – Swing point not broken – so still bearish
  • Market Cycle needs work (Trend -> Trading Range -> Trend)
  • Scaling in makes no sense – buying bear bars when always on short
  • Intrabar scaling-in
  • How to trade a Trading Range

Trade 3:

Suggested exercises to practice:

  • Breakout and pullbacks
  • Scale ins
  • Keeping the original trade and not changing it mid-way through the trade.
  • Confusing breakout trading with trading range trading

Conclusion

  • A big thank you to those traders who kindly let me review their trades.
  • If you would like me to review your trades here please get in touch.
  • Practice this on your trades for last week and I guarantee you will start to move the needle on your performance.

Leave a comment

I’m Tim

Welcome to Zen Trading Tech.

I’m a Aussie day trader and I post trading tips, practice drills, and indicators that helped my trading get to a professional level.

Everything here is to help train the eyes and hands to trade better. If it helped me I’ll post it for others. Hope you enjoy!